My quick rating - 2.2/10. Oh boy. First things first. No movie called Amityville Karen should be 103 minutes long. My own fault for watching, but I shouldn't have to say that. If you're making one of these micro-budget Amityville cash grabs, keep it under 90 minutes. Hell, under 80 would be even better.
The premise is exactly as ridiculous as it sounds. Karen (Lauren Francesca) is a cold, miserable health inspector who makes everyone around her suffer. After stealing a cursed bottle of wine from a struggling brewery, she ends up possessed and begins murdering people while delivering customer service complaints. Apparently even demonic possession can't stop her from asking to see the manager.
Oddly enough, the opening credits surprised me, looking somewhat professional. They almost have that polished Hallmark movie vibe before everything falls off a cliff. We meet Karen in bed, where she wastes absolutely no time complaining about landscapers outside her window just to make sure nobody misses the joke. Then creepy music kicks in for the title card because...Amityville Karen.
One pleasant surprise is that when Karen starts driving, she's actually in a moving car instead of pretending to drive in front of a green screen. My standards are low here, so yes, that counts as praise.
Francesca commits to playing the world's most insufferable Karen, and seriously, she seems a little too comfortable in the role. Whenever she's berating people, she's actually entertaining enough. Unfortunately, every time she breaks into her evil villain laugh, things go downhill in a hurry.
The cursed wine introduces some bizarre moments. Karen dreams about a half-naked dancing woman before Barnaby (Carl Solomon) shows up at her door carrying a blood contract that needs signing. Sure, why not sign it? This is Amityville. Barnaby is easily one of the funniest characters in the movie and steals just about every scene he's in.
One gag I actually laughed at was Karen talking in her sleep.
"I want to see your manager..."
"I need a refund..."
She repeats complaint after complaint while asleep, and it's probably the biggest laugh the movie managed to get out of me.
Unfortunately, once the story reaches the winery, things become painfully awkward. The wine tasting is loaded with cardboard-cutout patrons, an aggressively annoying band, and enough second-hand embarrassment to pair nicely with the cursed cabernet. The lead singer, Captain (Mike Ferguson), looked familiar, and sure enough, he'd previously turned up in Night Patrol.
The first kill isn't particularly convincing, but at least it's done with practical effects. Karen then wanders around dispatching people one by one, attaching some new complaint or customer grievance to every murder. It's a decent enough running joke, but there's simply not enough story surrounding it.
The acting outside of Francesca and Solomon is rough. Really rough. It often feels like director/Alex Shawn C. Phillips simply let everyone improvise entire conversations and hoped something funny would happen. Most of the time...it doesn't. There are even moments where weapons visibly miss their targets by a mile. Those scissors weren't fooling anybody.
Julie Anne Prescott wrote Amityville Karen, and anyone familiar with low-budget indie horror has probably seen her name before. This falls squarely into that same category of B-movie schlock. The problem isn't the silly premise. That's actually part of the appeal. It's that there's barely enough plot for an hour, let alone 103 minutes.
I probably would've bumped this out of full #turkey territory if it had simply wrapped things up sooner.
Instead, after the winery sequence finally ends, the movie somehow gets even worse.
The final ten minutes become an endless parade of fake news reports featuring what has to be every crowdfunding supporter who paid for a cameo. One after another after another after another. It's painfully obvious why they're there, and instead of sprinkling these appearances throughout the movie, they're dumped on us all at once. Watching random people awkwardly deliver news reports for ten straight minutes is one of the most irritating ways I've ever seen a movie pad its runtime.

At least the credits looked nice. That's something.
https://jackmeat.com/amityville-karen-2022/




