My quick rating - 6.3/10. Melissa Benoist was so good as Supergirl in the TV series that I knew I was going to have a hard time not comparing the new version to her. So I decided to wait until the end before passing judgment on Milly Alcock.
We start with This Summer by Sleigh Bells blasting away, which immediately made me grin. And yes, this is the same band I found years ago and apparently never shut up about. James Gunn clearly had some influence on the musical choices here, even though Craig Gillespie directs, because nobody drops a song into a superhero movie quite like Gunn.
We get a quick look at Kara Zor-El's life before things go sideways. She's carefree, having fun and hanging out with a very cute dog. Then the music shifts into something ominous as a ship races past, and we get our first look at Planet Holzherr, sitting in the solar Red category. A brief confrontation involving Krem (Matthias Schoenaerts) goes badly for the sellers, and we're off.
Kara eventually finds herself drinking in a bar populated by a wonderfully weird collection of alien creatures. In a drunken stupor, she helps Ruthye (Eve Ridley), whose family was murdered during the opening events. Kara initially wants nothing to do with the girl's quest for revenge, but Krem shoots Krypto with a poison dart, steals Kara's ship and gives her 72 hours to save the dog.
Well, there goes the "I don't want to get involved" plan.
The interstellar adventure that follows is a lot of fun at times, and when Kara stops for information, we finally get Jason Momoa as Lobo. This is such an obvious and inspired casting choice that it's quite annoying how little of him we get.
We also get a nicely done look at Krypton's history, although the movie does ask me to accept that alien civilizations across the universe apparently all agreed that looking exactly like humans was the way to go. Even the dogs. Come on, guys. You have an entire universe to work with.
Eve Ridley does a good job with Ruthye, but the character itself becomes increasingly irritating. They really pushed making this kid a pain in the ass, and several of the increasingly bad situations are caused by her decisions. That's not a knock on Ridley's performance, but I kept wondering whether I was watching Supergirl or Ruthye's Extremely Expensive Space Adventure Featuring Supergirl.
David Corenswet's Superman eventually shows up, more or less as a tour guide. We get another sequence where one person spins around while everything explodes around them, which immediately reminded me of The Flash. I also found myself wondering why Superman didn't simply pick her up and fly away. Because apparently that isn't cinematic enough. I did like how the sequence resolves, and the Superman/Supergirl conversation afterward is one of the better moments in the movie.
My bigger problem is the screenplay.
There's nothing terribly wrong with Supergirl. It's entertaining, visually polished, and has some good performances. Alcock works well as Kara, particularly with this younger, more carefree version of the character. But considering the talent involved and the money on screen, it should have had far more punch. The script feels surprisingly weak, and the story never quite develops the oomph it seems to be reaching for.
I'm also not completely sold on the Guardians of the Galaxy meets DC Supergirl approach. I understand the intention. It gives Kara a bigger universe to explore instead of keeping her stuck in Superman's shadow on Earth. But something about the combination never quite clicked for me.
And I kept coming back to the same question: Is Supergirl actually the main character here?
The camera certainly seemed convinced it was Ruthye.

Still, Supergirl isn't a bad movie. Alcock is good, the action works, the interstellar setting is fun, and there are enough entertaining moments. I just wanted that extra something. That little superhero movie that makes you walk out thinking, "Hell yeah."
Instead, I was left thinking, "That was pretty good." Oh, and not enough Lobo!
Which might actually be the biggest crime in the whole movie. Damn, I need to stop typing LOL.
https://jackmeat.com/supergirl-2026/




